Every year, the federal government is supposed to follow a structured budget process: the President proposes, Congress disposes, agencies execute. In practice, the process is a rolling disaster of missed deadlines, continuing resolutions, and 11th-hour omnibus bills.
Congress hasn't passed all 12 appropriations bills on time since 1997. That's 28 years of budget dysfunction. The "process" is a fiction. Here's what actually happens.
How It's Supposed to Work
President's Budget (February)
The President submits a budget request to Congress. This is a wish list — Congress ignores most of it. Presidents from both parties have called it "dead on arrival."
Budget Resolution (April 15)
Congress is supposed to pass a budget resolution setting overall spending limits. This often doesn't happen at all.
Appropriations Bills (by October 1)
12 individual appropriations bills fund different parts of the government. Each is supposed to pass both chambers. This almost never happens on time.
Fiscal Year Begins (October 1)
The new fiscal year starts. Agencies need funding to operate. If bills haven't passed, they need a continuing resolution.
How It Actually Works
In reality, the process looks like this:
February: President submits budget.
Congress says "that's nice" and ignores it.
March-September: Committees hold hearings.
Members grandstand. Nothing passes.
October 1: Fiscal year begins. No bills passed.
Congress passes a continuing resolution (CR) to keep the lights on.
October-December: More CRs, shutdown threats.
Political brinksmanship. Cable news goes wall-to-wall.
December/January: Omnibus bill.
Leadership negotiates a massive bill behind closed doors. Members get hours to read a 4,000-page bill. It passes because the alternative is a shutdown.
📚 What's an Omnibus Bill?
An omnibus bill bundles all 12 (or most) appropriations bills into a single massive package. The FY2023 omnibus was 4,155 pages long and cost $1.7 trillion. Members had about 24 hours to read it before voting. Nobody reads it. They just vote yes to avoid a shutdown, then claim credit for whatever goodies their staff inserted.
Mandatory vs. Discretionary: The Big Divide
Here's the dirty secret of the budget: Congress only controls about one-third of total spending through annual appropriations. The rest is "mandatory" — it happens automatically.
| Type | Amount | % of Budget | Examples |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mandatory | ~$4.5T | ~65% | Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid |
| Discretionary | ~$1.8T | ~27% | Defense, education, NASA, FBI |
| Net Interest | ~$1.25T | ~12% | Interest on the debt |
This means the entire budget "process" — the hearings, the negotiations, the shutdowns — is about less than a third of what the government actually spends. The other two-thirds runs on autopilot. To change mandatory spending, Congress would need to change the underlying laws (Social Security Act, Medicare Act, etc.), which is politically radioactive.
Government Shutdowns: Political Theater
Since 1976, there have been 22 funding gaps, including several multi-week shutdowns. The longest was 35 days in 2018-2019. Shutdowns furlough "non-essential" federal employees, close national parks, delay tax refunds, and create uncertainty — but they don't actually save money. Federal workers get back pay when the shutdown ends, and the disruption costs more than it saves.
| Shutdown | Duration | Workers Furloughed | Cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2013 (Obama/GOP) | 16 days | 800,000 | $24B in economic damage |
| 2018 (Trump) | 3 days | Limited | Minimal |
| 2018-19 (Trump) | 35 days | 800,000 | $11B in GDP |
| 2023 (avoided) | 0 days | 0 | Hours from shutdown |
The Debt Ceiling: A Separate Crisis
The debt ceiling is a separate statutory limit on how much the government can borrow. It's not about new spending — it's about paying for spending Congress already authorized. Think of it as refusing to pay your credit card bill after you've already bought the stuff.
Congress has raised or suspended the debt ceiling 78 times since 1960. It's always raised eventually, but the brinksmanship causes market jitters, credit downgrades, and political chaos every time.
The Bottom Line
The federal budget "process" is broken. Congress hasn't followed its own rules in nearly three decades. The result is governance by crisis: shutdowns, continuing resolutions, and omnibus bills that nobody reads. Two-thirds of spending happens on autopilot, and the third that Congress controls is subject to political hostage-taking every year.
If you ran your household finances this way — missing every deadline, refusing to budget, then cramming everything into a last-minute emergency — you'd be bankrupt. The government avoids that fate only because it can print money and borrow at will. For now.
More Analysis
Where Your Taxes Actually Go
A cent-by-cent breakdown of every dollar Washington spends — and why most Americans have no idea.
Spending ComparisonDefense vs. Education: America's Spending Priorities
We spend 12x more on the military than the Department of Education. Is that the right balance?
Waste & FraudThe $247 Billion Waste Machine
Improper payments, fraud, and the GAO's high-risk list — a taxpayer's guide to government waste.
National DebtThe $34 Trillion Time Bomb
Interest on the debt now costs more than national defense. Here's how we got here — and where we're headed.