Every year, the federal government makes $247 billion in improper payments — money sent to the wrong person, in the wrong amount, or for the wrong reason. That's not an estimate from some think tank. It's the government's own number.
To put that in context: $247 billion is more than the entire budget of the Department of Veterans Affairs. It's more than we spend on transportation, education, and science combined. And it happens every single year.
Annual Improper Payments
$247B
Government's own estimate
Since 2003
$2.7T+
Cumulative improper payments
Recovery Rate
~1%
Of improper payments recovered
The GAO High-Risk List
The Government Accountability Office (GAO) maintains a "High-Risk List" of federal programs vulnerable to waste, fraud, abuse, and mismanagement. The 2023 list includes 37 areas covering hundreds of billions in spending. Some have been on the list for over 30 years.
| Program | Years on List | Est. Waste/Risk |
|---|---|---|
| Medicare | Since 1990 | $46.3B/year in improper payments |
| Medicaid | Since 2003 | $80.6B/year in improper payments |
| Earned Income Tax Credit | Since 2002 | $21.9B/year in improper payments |
| DOD Financial Management | Since 1995 | Cannot pass audit |
| DOD Weapon Systems | Since 1990 | $2T+ in cost overruns |
| NASA Acquisition | Since 1990 | Chronic cost overruns |
| IT Acquisitions | Since 2015 | $100B+/year with poor results |
| VA Health Care | Since 2015 | Scheduling, access, quality |
| Government-wide Personnel | Since 2001 | Skills gaps across agencies |
🤯 30 Years and Counting
DOD Weapon Systems Acquisition has been on the GAO High-Risk List since 1990. That's 35 years of being flagged for waste — spanning six presidents, multiple wars, and trillions in spending. Nothing has changed.
The Greatest Hits of Government Waste
$80.6 Billion: Medicaid Improper Payments
Medicaid — the joint federal-state health program for low-income Americans — has an improper payment rate of 21.7%. That means more than one in five dollars is paid incorrectly. This includes payments for ineligible people, incorrect amounts, and services never rendered. States have little incentive to crack down because the federal government picks up 50-90% of the tab.
$46.3 Billion: Medicare Improper Payments
Medicare's improper payment rate is lower than Medicaid's (about 7.7%), but the total dollar amount is staggering. Common issues include billing for services not provided, upcoding (billing for a more expensive procedure than performed), and payments to deceased beneficiaries. Yes, the government sends checks to dead people. A lot of them.
$200+ Billion: COVID Relief Fraud
The pandemic spending programs were fraud magnets. The Small Business Administration's Inspector General estimated that at least $200 billion in PPP and EIDL loans were fraudulent. The rush to distribute funds meant virtually no verification. Prisoners, identity thieves, and organized crime rings all got checks.
Pentagon Spending: Where Audits Go to Die
The Department of Defense has never passed an audit. It can't account for $3.8 trillion in assets. In one memorable example, auditors found that the Army made $6.5 trillion in accounting adjustments in a single quarter — more than the entire federal budget. These weren't real transactions; they were bookkeeping entries to make the numbers balance. The Army was literally making up numbers.
Why Nothing Changes
The obvious question: if we know about $247 billion in improper payments, why don't we stop them? Several reasons:
Nobody Gets Fired
Federal employees have near-total job security. In 2023, the federal firing rate was 0.5% — compared to about 3% in the private sector. There are essentially no consequences for waste.
Perverse Incentives
Agencies that don't spend their full budget get less money next year. This creates a "use it or lose it" culture where waste is rewarded and frugality is punished.
Political Cover
Both parties benefit from spending. Republicans funnel money to defense contractors in their districts. Democrats protect social program budgets. Neither side wants real accountability.
Complexity as Shield
The federal government is so vast that waste hides in complexity. With $10+ trillion flowing through thousands of programs, bad spending is a needle in a haystack of haystacks.
What Would $247 Billion Buy?
If we recovered all improper payments for just one year, we could:
| Alternative Use | Cost |
|---|---|
| Eliminate all federal student loan interest for 3 years | $75B/year |
| Double the NIH research budget | $47B |
| Fund NASA for 10 years | $25B/year |
| Give every American household $2,000 | $260B |
| Rebuild every structurally deficient bridge in America | $125B |
💰 The Real Question
Government waste isn't a bug — it's a feature of a system with no competition, no accountability, and no consequences. The private sector wastes money too, but companies that waste enough go bankrupt. The government just borrows more.
The Bottom Line
The federal government wastes more money every year than the GDP of most countries. The GAO identifies the problems. Inspectors general document the fraud. Reports are written, hearings are held, and press releases are issued. And then nothing changes. The same programs waste the same money year after year, decade after decade.
If you want to understand why Americans are cynical about government, start here: $247 billion in known waste, and a recovery rate of about 1%. Your tax dollars, going up in smoke, with nobody accountable.
More Analysis
Where Your Taxes Actually Go
A cent-by-cent breakdown of every dollar Washington spends — and why most Americans have no idea.
Spending ComparisonDefense vs. Education: America's Spending Priorities
We spend 12x more on the military than the Department of Education. Is that the right balance?
National DebtThe $34 Trillion Time Bomb
Interest on the debt now costs more than national defense. Here's how we got here — and where we're headed.
COVID SpendingWhere Did $6 Trillion in COVID Money Go?
The largest spending spree in American history — PPP fraud, EIDL abuse, and trillions with little oversight.